Jane's Carousel

Jane's Carousel

New York City, USA

You should be looking at a glass box on the waterfront.

You should be looking at a glass box on the waterfront. Inside that box is a carousel. Forty-eight hand-carved wooden horses and two chariots, built in nineteen twenty-two in Philadelphia. Originally installed at Idora Park in Youngstown, Ohio — back when Youngstown was a booming steel city.

When Idora Park closed in nineteen eighty-four, the carousel was put up for auction. It was about to be sold off piece by piece — individual horses to collectors, the machine scrapped. A woman named Jane Walentas bought the whole thing for three hundred eighty-five thousand dollars.

Then she took it home and spent the next twenty-seven years fixing it. With an X-Acto knife.

Sixty-two years of accumulated park paint — layer after layer of cheap color slapped on between seasons. Jane scraped it off by hand. Horse by horse. Inch by inch. Uncovering the original nineteen twenty-two color palette and the fine detail of the original carvings. She photographed every discovery. Made color matches. Drew

restoration guides. Horse by horse. For twenty-seven years.

During the restoration, her husband David — the developer who'd bought most of DUMBO for twelve million dollars — reportedly brought a potential buyer to the studio. The buyer offered twelve million for the unfinished carousel. Jane didn't look up from the horse she was scraping and said: tell him it's not for sale. And tell him to close

Hear the full story

Hear this story with audio narration in the Bad Historian app.

Get the Free App

Quick Facts

  • PTC carousel built 1922 in Philadelphia; 48 hand-carved horses, 2 chariots
  • Originally at Idora Park, Youngstown, Ohio; Jane Walentas bought at auction 1984 for $385K
  • Jane spent 22-27 years restoring with X-Acto knife; 62 years of accumulated park paint
  • Total cost ~$15M restoration + $9M pavilion = ~$24M
  • Jean Nouvel (Pritzker Prize winner) designed acrylic pavilion; insisted on square not round
  • At night carousel casts shadows on pavilion walls like a magic lantern
  • Hurricane Sandy flooded carousel 13 months after opening; iconic photo of glowing carousel in floodwater
  • Jane Walentas died July 5, 2020 at age 76; street renamed Jane Walentas Way
Featured Tour

The Family Business

Several stops • 1h 30m

View Tour

Location

New York City, USA
Open in Maps