Musée d'Art et d'Histoire du Judaïsme — Hôtel de Saint-Aignan

Musée d'Art et d'Histoire du Judaïsme — Hôtel de Saint-Aignan

Paris, France

The great carriage door at seventy-one Rue du Temple hides one of the finest mansions in the Marais. The mansion, in turn, is hiding something of its own.

The great carriage door at seventy-one Rue du Temple hides one of the finest mansions in the Marais. The mansion, in turn, is hiding something of its own. This is the Hotel de Saint-Aignan, built in the sixteen forties for the Count d'Avaux. He was the diplomat who helped negotiate the treaty that ended the Thirty Years' War. A man who spent his career making things look settled, living in a house built on the same principle.

Because inside that courtyard, one entire wing of the mansion is fake. When the architect laid out the court, a leftover chunk of Paris's medieval city wall stood in the way. There was no room to build the matching wing that symmetry demanded. So he built the FRONT of one. A full facade — windows, cornices, pilasters, everything — carved in relief against a blank wall, with nothing behind it. French architects have a name for the trick. A fox wall. The count went further and had real flues run up behind it, so the chimneys of his imaginary wing could smoke when h

e entertained. For nearly four hundred years, first-time visitors have looked at that wall and seen rooms that were never there.

When the aristocracy drifted off to Versailles, the mansion began a long slide downhill. By the eighteen hundreds it had been carved into dozens of small workshops and apartments. The people who filled them were Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe — tailors, cap maker

Hear the full story

Hear this story with audio narration in the Bad Historian app.

Get the App

Quick Facts

  • The Hôtel de Saint-Aignan was built in the 1640s for the Count d'Avaux, the diplomat who helped negotiate the treaty that ended the Thirty Years' War
  • One entire wing of the courtyard is fake — a full trompe-l'oeil facade with windows, cornices, and pilasters carved against a blank wall, built because the medieval city wall left no room for a real matching wing; French architects call the trick a "fox wall"
  • By the 1800s the mansion had been subdivided into dozens of workshops and apartments housing Eastern European Jewish artisans — tailors, cap makers, furriers
  • Artist Christian Boltanski traced every 1939 resident through the archives and mounted plaques in the back court naming each one — a name, a trade, sometimes a fate — and asked that they never be restored, so they weather like memory
  • Since 1998 the building has housed France's national museum of Jewish art and history
Featured Tour

Le Marais: Mansions, Masterpieces & the Best Falafel in Europe

9 stops • 33 min

View Tour

Location

Paris, France
Open in Maps